eG8: copyright panel backfires on French Culture Minister
- Author: Monica Horten
- Published: 25 May 2011
The eG8 was meant to be President Sarkozy's showpiece event, an opportunity to gather together the great and the good of Internet and content industries and have them all listen to him. It preceding the main economic talks of the G8. But today the French culture Minister, Frédéric Mitterrand, had his nose put well out of joint. The rarified atmosphere of favoured copyright industry was infiltrated by copyleft viewpoints. A prestige panel on Internet content appears to have turned into a farce worthy of Beaumarchais himself, as M. Mitterand was put well out of his comfort zone by John Perry Barlow, and Jérémie Zimmermann (in this video) .
As outside the eG8, citizen activists attempted to alert the industry and government representatives to the problems of Sarkozy's plans to control the Internet, inside Frédéric Mitterrand, chaired a panel comprising four stalwarts of the copyright industries. They were Antoine Gallimard of Editions Gallimard, James Gianopulos of 20th Century Fox (Murdoch Corporation), Pascal Nègre, head of Universal Music France, and Hartmut Ostrowski of music publishers Bertelsmann. A last-minute invitee was John Perry Barlow, former musician with the Grateful Dead, founder of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and author of one of the seminal articles of the copyleft, The Economy of Ideas.
John Perry Barlow stirred things up quite a bit, according to
a report in the French journal MediaPart . At the end of what might be termed in Sarkozy-speak a ;'civilised' discussion where 20th Century fox agreed with the Minister that Hadopi is a good thing, Mr Barlow spoke up:
"I get the impression of being from another planet. A property is something you can take from me, that does not apply to expresion. You speak of content as if there existed a container which one could exchange, but that no longer exists. You are refuding to recognise that the Internet is a coninuous domain and if you try to control it, in order to protect intellectual property, you will finhs up by controlling freedom of expression..." This conference is only about imposing norms of another era onto the future... "
According to the report, a frustrated M. Mitterand started talking economics. But when Mr Barlow appeared to be more conversant with the figures, the Minister wanted to hear no more.
Jérémie Zimmermann of La Quadrature du Net jumped in to the question and answer session, and told the Minister that industry needs to change to meet the needs of users and not the other way around. Watch the video carefully for the reaction of Frédéric Mitterrand and the copyright industry panelists.
A round table on innovation included Lawrence Lessig. According to a report in PC Inpact, Lessig
told the French government that the Hadopi scheme would be still-born. This idea of a graduated response benefits those who are already in place, but ignores innovation. And he called on the G8 governments to protect open access and a neutral network.
The correct attribution for this article is: Monica Horten (2011) eG8: copyright panel backfires on French Culture Minister http://www.iptegrity.com 25 May 2011 .
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial-Share Alike 2.5 UK:England and Wales License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/2.0/uk/ It may be used for non-commercial purposes only, and the author's name should be attributed.
- Article Views: 10007
IPtegrity politics
- EU at loggerheads over chat control
- Why the Online Safety Act is not fit for purpose
- Fixing the human rights failings in the Online Safety Act
- Whatever happened to the AI Bill?
- Hidden effects of the UK Online Safety Act
- EU puts chat control on back burner
- Why did X lock my account for not providing my birthday?
- Creation of deep fakes to be criminal offence under new law
- AI and tech: Asks for the new government
- How WhatsApp holds structural power
- Meta rolls out encryption as political headwinds ease
- EU law set for new course on child online safety
- Online Safety Act: Ofcom’s 1700-pages of tech platform rules
- MEPs reach political agreement to protect children and privacy
- Online Safety - a non-consensual Act
- Not a blank cheque: European Parliament consents to EU-UK Agreement
- UK border safety alert - mind the capability gap
About Iptegrity
Iptegrity.com is the website of Dr Monica Horten, independent policy advisor: online safety, technology and human rights. Advocating to protect the rights of the majority of law abiding citizens online. Independent expert on the Council of Europe Committee of Experts on online safety and empowerment of content creators and users. Published author, and post-doctoral scholar, with a PhD from the University of Westminster, and a DipM from the Chartered Institute of Marketing. Former telecoms journalist, experienced panelist and Chair, cited in the media eg BBC, iNews, Times, Guardian and Politico.
Politics & copyright
A Copyright Masquerade: How Corporate Lobbying Threatens Online Freedoms
'timely and provocative' Entertainment Law Review
Online Safety
- Why the Online Safety Act is not fit for purpose
- Fixing the human rights failings in the Online Safety Act
- Hidden effects of the UK Online Safety Act
- Why did X lock my account for not providing my birthday?
- Online Safety Act: Ofcom’s 1700-pages of tech platform rules
- Online Safety - a non-consensual Act
- Online Safety Bill passes as US court blocks age-checks law
- Online Safety Bill: ray of hope for free speech
- National Crime Agency to run new small boats social media centre
- Online Safety Bill: does government want to snoop on your WhatsApps?
- What is content of democratic importance?
- Online Safety Bill: One rule for them and another for us
- Online Safety Bill - Freedom to interfere?
- Copyright-style website blocking orders slipped into Online Safety Bill
- 2 billion cost to British businesses for Online Safety Bill